Actor-Network Theory
Energy Transitions
Multilevel Perspective (MLP)
Área
Gestão Socioambiental
Tema
Desenvolvimento Sustentável e os ODSs
Autores
Nome
1 - Gabriela Almeida Marcon Nora UNIVERSIDADE DO VALE DO ITAJAÍ (UNIVALI) - Programa de Pós-Graduação em Administração - PPGA - Biguaçu (SC)
2 - Anete Alberton UNIVERSIDADE DO VALE DO ITAJAÍ (UNIVALI) - PPGA - PMPGIL / UNIVALI
Reumo
Energy, among the components of the infrastructure, is perhaps the one with the greatest range of interactions and environmental impacts. Part of the energy industry is the electric energy market or electricity sector. Electricity is today in most people's daily activities. The electrification of services and the digitization of human relationships make us increasingly dependent on energy. Different transition paths may coexist. In order to analyze the role of actors and accommodate consumption, cultural, and sociopolitical dimensions, the multilevel perspective framework (MLP).
Brazil stands out on the world stage using three times more renewable sources than the average. The analysis of the sociopolitical interactions provides a better understanding of the role of these actors in the transition paths. The guiding question that arises is: What are the main disruptive actors to foster the energy transition process in Brazil? This paper aims to contextualize how actors involved in the process of energy transition in the Brazilian electricity sector relate in a multilevel perspective (MLP).
The Actor-Network Theory can help to define and coordinate functions within a social structure comprising both social and natural. Actors or actants are anything that can act or change the actions of another through associations that change the state of things. The past and the present matter to define the actors. Stakeholder Theory offers tools to prioritize the interests that will be decisive for promoting an energy transition. Our theoretical background approaches the two theories to address the actors in energy transitions. The MLP can help to visualize actors in the field.
A documental case study was performed. In documentary research, the source of data collection is restricted to documents, written or not, constituting what is called secondary sources. Literature was the starting point for the analysis, as it would not be possible to find the problems to be faced in the field without a preliminary reading. Content analysis is used to enrich an exploratory analysis and obtain quick notions about a text, identifying key ideas and helping qualitative analysis. The history and description of current policies are important to understand the analyzed documents.
Results present a brief history and prospect of electricity industry in Brazil. Also, presents actants of the Brazilian Electricity Sector in a Multilevel Perspective. Brazil, unlike other countries, has a multiplicity of energy resources at its disposal and needs to manage in the best way to promote energy efficiency. The electricity market in Brazil is highly regulated, with different institutional agents, which can make changes difficult due to, sometimes, non-economic barriers.
Despite criticisms about its simplicity and adequacy to contexts other than the one in which it theoretically emerged; we consider MLP to be a very useful framework for the study in question. Three major categories emerged from the case study: (i) institutional actors - among which are government actors, (ii) Civil Society and financial agents, and (iii) technological & environmental actors. From the analysis of the Brazilian scenario, we sense that the three possible groups of actors coexist at the multiple levels of the MLP, exchanging views and influencing each other.
Geels, F.W. (2004). From sectoral systems of innovation to socio-technical systems: Insights about dynamics and change from sociology and institutional theory. Research Policy, 33(6-7), 897-920.
Tolmasquim, M. T., de Barros Correia, T., Porto, N. A., & Kruger, W. (2021). Electricity market design and renewable energy auctions: The case of Brazil. Energy Policy, 158, 112558.
Valkenburg, G., & Cotella, G. (2016). Governance of energy transitions: about inclusion and closure in complex socio-technical problems. Energy, Sustainability & Society, 6(1), 1-11.